Showing posts with label J. J. Abrams. Show all posts
Showing posts with label J. J. Abrams. Show all posts

Sunday, March 27, 2016

Review: 10 Cloverfield Lane

This will be the first of two posts on 10 Cloverfield Lane, first is a review of the film itself and the second will be a genre study. This first part is spoiler free and the other will have marked spoilers.


How you respond to Bad Robot's new production 10 Cloverfield Lane will almost certainly depend on how much you were expecting a sequel to 2008's Cloverfield.

First-time director Dan Trachtenberg's movie has little-to-no connection to the first Cloverfield, but it's also destined to suffer disinterest or even rejection from two extremes: anybody who was hoping to see the original story continued; and also haters of the original who are turned off by the use of the title for this new movie.

For what it's worth, I found some enjoyment in the original film but hoped that whatever Matt Reeves directed next wasn't as aggressively average and doused in shaky-camera antics (I was rewarded in 2014 with his flawed but great Dawn of the Planet of the Apes). If you were in the same camp, you probably weren't clamouring for Cloverfield 2. However, you might be better positioned to enjoy 10 Cloverfield Lane.

Mary Elizabeth Winstead is Michelle, who after an argument with her fiance leaves New Orleans and drives out to the country. She has an accident on the highway and blacks out, only to wake up inside an underground bunker owned by Howard (John Goodman). Howard is a conspiracy nut and disaster prepper who alleges that there's been "attack" above ground and, as far as he knows, Michelle, he and a third survivor, Emmett, are all that remain of the human race.

So begins a no-fat rollercoaster ride filled with mystery and tension, grounded in fantastic performances by the two leads. Goodman is intriguing (given the twisted story structure of reveal upon reveal) and is alternately welcoming and frightening. His potential untrustworthiness – whether intentional or simply by his being an "outsider" – is a good parallel to your reaction while watching the film. Has Howard rescued Michelle, or simply kidnapped her and invented a catastrophe? Is he the antagonist of the story? His he a "monster", much like the kaiju Clover? Is the movie even science-fiction? You won't get a peep from me.

Winstead, on the other hand, brings to life one of the best protagonists of the year so far. Her story-arc is core from minute 1 through minute 103 (the movie is 103 minutes long). It's uplifting to see a film whose production staff were dedicated to providing cathartic character growth and at the same time not shirking the horror of being trapped in a confined space with people you don't know.

The acting isn't the only thing that keeps you engaged. Battlestar's Bear McCreary provides a fitting original score, though you could say that it is closer to the Bad Robot "house style" than Bear's own. What his music truly succeeds at is blending into the sonic fabric of Howard's bunker. When Michelle is feeling emotional, that's the accompaniment. When she is surprised, the strings will sting.

Yes, there are jump scares in the movie. Yes, like many mysteries, once you know the outcome the tension will probably be deflated on future viewings. Despite this, I take issue at the idea that these will sour 10 Cloverfield Lane with time. Like Psycho (more on that in the next post) the world suggested within the story is layered and interesting enough that you will never be bored, even knowing exactly what happens next. In the end, the film is a high-quality experience either way, with great twists and believable characters.

But what about the Cloverfield connection? Do you need to have seen the first movie at all to get more out of 10 Cloverfield Lane? The answer is a resounding no. Abrams and company have made it clear with this sudden departure and subsequent interviews that the idea of a true sequel to Cloverfield is less interesting than using the strange, smaller-budget associations of that title to tell what amounts to a sci-fi anthology series, like a big-screen Twilight Zone. That might be the most thrilling part …

10 Cloverfield Lane earns 4.5 / 5 stars.



Stay tuned for another look at 10 Cloverfield Lane next, with a focus on how it fits into the cinematic canon of "high-quality B-movies".

Monday, December 28, 2015

Remember the rule of three

It took me actually reading the script of Super 8 to finally realise what always irks me about J. J. Abrams' movies -- and why it doesn't necessarily irritate everyone. Here's a storyteller who (whether through directorial choices or the script he writes) doesn't care much for the rule of three, and pays only the meanest mind to foreshadowing.

The most glaring example (also the least in this argument, but I'll include it because J. J. was still responsible for the final product) was Star Trek Into Darkness, where Khan's super-blood is discovered by Bones to have healing properties because of his testing it on a dead tribble. The only tribble seen beforehand was the painfully ham-handed inclusion of Bones saying "I'm testing Khan's super-blood on a dead tribble because I think it might have healing properties." Cheers Orci and Kurtzman -- as though the rope afforded to a Noo Star Trek ("no longer sci-fi but an action movie instead") is also enough to have a poorly constructed denouement, even for a bad action movie.

Lucky, for fans of his other strengths, Mr Abrams isn't quite so brazenly bad at setting up plots, but in his own self-written movies we still see a lack of respect for the rule of three and foreshadowing. Take Super 8: the reason I decided to write this rant in the first place. Now those of us who dislike the end third of this film share a variety of story and thematic reasons for why it doesn't work -- chief among these (thanks Film Crit Hulk) being how the movie itself lacks evidence in its own understanding of what it wants to do with character resolution and themes. But the movie actually does know what it wants to say: it's just that there's not enough evidence that it does.

At the moment during the end when the alien picks up Joe, according to the shooting script the look it gives him with suddenly human-like eyes is 100% a callback to the Joe and Alice watching home movies scene (where she revealed her father's involvement in Joe's mother's death).

Here's the rub: if you want a particular idea (in this case "the eyes that see within") to sink in, you repeat it. This, in narrative language, highlights to the audience an intentional foreshadowing, rather than world-building or character filigree. You could in fact set aside other major problems with the ending of Super 8 ---

1. the tired cliché of human-like features cluing the audience to "oh, the scary alien's not so bad" (by gum, DOGS do this to us, it's not the most inventive idea), and

2. the fact that Joel Courtney's portrayal of Joe on screen (while captivating) is nowhere close to the suffering, loner tween that the final money shot needed him to be (thanks again to the Hulk -- the contrast between pre-letting-go-of-the-locket-Joe and the theoretical "better" Joe we hope for after the end of the movie just isn't there, he's too well adjusted) --

--- if you had just followed the rule of three, we'd be more inclined to believe "the eyes that see within" was reminiscent of Joe's mother. In other words, the ending of this still-flawed film could have been improved dramatically if the story had just used the rule of three for foreshadowing.

STAR WARS EPISODE VII SPOILERS INCOMING

---


---


---


---


You can see the effect of following the rule contrasted with breaking it in the villain and hero of The Force Awakens -- Kylo Ren's struggle with the light sticks to the rule and so it is believable that in remedying his struggle he takes action, because we have had the issue first introduced, then developed at least once before it becomes important. Rule of three.

Conversely, all around the Internet, the detractors of Rey's arc cry foul at how improbably powerful she becomes during the final battle. A moment that was telegraphed when Maz Kanata tells her, part way into the film, that the Force is calling to her: that she has huge potential and she only needs to close her eyes and let it in. (Funny, I just realised that both this and the Super 8 example are "the eyes". Perhaps a running motif in Abrams' work, like super-blood in Orci and Kurtzman's?). You have to remember, and this part is well established, that Rey is not familiar with even hearing the word "Force", and so when Kylo offers to teach her in its ways, it is the mention of the word that causes Rey to recall Maz's teaching. Even with the other key developments with her use of the Force, between Maz and the climactic duel we never have that middle dialogue reference to "letting the Force in" that is necessary for the rule of three.

If the mention of the Force calling to Rey and her needing to let it in was developed before it became important once more in the fight with Kylo, I am fairly convinced that there would be fewer complaints about the apparent "ass pull". After all, one of the more acclaimed positives was Kylo's aforementioned struggle, which had the appropriate development.

For all we know, the infamously cut "Maz goes to the Resistance Base" sequence might have given us the developing mention of letting the Force in. In the final product, however, it doesn't matter because (and I'm being quite presumptuous here), Abrams cares more for pace, energy and ruthlessly propulsive editing than he does for whether or not viewers pick up an important motivational cue; one that can massage potential plot holes and appease narrative dorks like myself.